Anarcho-Republicanism?: Arendt and the Federated Council System

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

A number of scholars have seen in Arendt's writing on council democracy a useful model for contemporary anarchist movements. While Arendt praises anarchists like Proudhon and Bakunin for their contribution to council politics, she surprisingly argues that these radicals were "singularly unequipped to deal with a phenomenon [which] aimed at the foundation of a new state and the establishment of a new form of government." This criticism - indeed, one of the only direct comments she makes about anarchism - is odd for a number of reasons, and it seems to say much more about her views of Proudhon and Bakunin than it does about the compatibility of her thought with anarchism, in general. Indeed, Arendt's thought is much more compatible with anarchism than her criticism suggests.
Original languageEnglish
JournalScience and Society
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

anarchism
republicanism
criticism
democracy
politics

Cite this

Anarcho-Republicanism?: Arendt and the Federated Council System. / Smith, Brian.

In: Science and Society, 2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{adae20d3203c4168a0f11efa1f62f79d,
title = "Anarcho-Republicanism?: Arendt and the Federated Council System",
abstract = "A number of scholars have seen in Arendt's writing on council democracy a useful model for contemporary anarchist movements. While Arendt praises anarchists like Proudhon and Bakunin for their contribution to council politics, she surprisingly argues that these radicals were {"}singularly unequipped to deal with a phenomenon [which] aimed at the foundation of a new state and the establishment of a new form of government.{"} This criticism - indeed, one of the only direct comments she makes about anarchism - is odd for a number of reasons, and it seems to say much more about her views of Proudhon and Bakunin than it does about the compatibility of her thought with anarchism, in general. Indeed, Arendt's thought is much more compatible with anarchism than her criticism suggests.",
author = "Brian Smith",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1521/siso.2019.83.1.87",
language = "English",
journal = "Science and Society",
issn = "0036-8237",
publisher = "Guilford Publications",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Anarcho-Republicanism?: Arendt and the Federated Council System

AU - Smith, Brian

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - A number of scholars have seen in Arendt's writing on council democracy a useful model for contemporary anarchist movements. While Arendt praises anarchists like Proudhon and Bakunin for their contribution to council politics, she surprisingly argues that these radicals were "singularly unequipped to deal with a phenomenon [which] aimed at the foundation of a new state and the establishment of a new form of government." This criticism - indeed, one of the only direct comments she makes about anarchism - is odd for a number of reasons, and it seems to say much more about her views of Proudhon and Bakunin than it does about the compatibility of her thought with anarchism, in general. Indeed, Arendt's thought is much more compatible with anarchism than her criticism suggests.

AB - A number of scholars have seen in Arendt's writing on council democracy a useful model for contemporary anarchist movements. While Arendt praises anarchists like Proudhon and Bakunin for their contribution to council politics, she surprisingly argues that these radicals were "singularly unequipped to deal with a phenomenon [which] aimed at the foundation of a new state and the establishment of a new form of government." This criticism - indeed, one of the only direct comments she makes about anarchism - is odd for a number of reasons, and it seems to say much more about her views of Proudhon and Bakunin than it does about the compatibility of her thought with anarchism, in general. Indeed, Arendt's thought is much more compatible with anarchism than her criticism suggests.

U2 - 10.1521/siso.2019.83.1.87

DO - 10.1521/siso.2019.83.1.87

M3 - Article

JO - Science and Society

JF - Science and Society

SN - 0036-8237

ER -