Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site

Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests

Valeriy F. Stepanenko, Masaharu Hoshi, Ian K. Bailiff, Alexander I. Ivannikov, Shin Toyoda, Masayoshi Yamamoto, Steven L. Simon, Masatsugu Matsuo, Noriyuki Kawano, Zhaxybay Zhumadilov, Masao S. Sasaki, Rafail I. Rosenson, Kazbek N. Apsalikov

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

22 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The paper is an analytical overview of the main results presented at the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop in Hiroshima (9-11 of March 2005), where different aspects of the dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site (SNTS) were discussed and summarized. The results of the international intercomparison of the retrospective luminescence dosimetry (RLD) method for Dolon' village (Kazakhstan) were presented at the Workshop and good concurrence between dose estimations by different laboratories from 6 countries (Japan, Russia, USA, Germany, Finland and UK) was pointed out. The accumulated dose values in brick for a common depth of 10 mm depth obtained independently by all participating laboratories were in good agreement for all four brick samples from Dolon' village, Kazakhstan, with the average value of the local gamma dose due to fallout (near the sampling locations) being about 220 mGy (background dose has been subtracted). Furthermore, using a conversion factor of about 2 to obtain the free-in-air dose, a value of local dose ∼ 440 mGy is obtained, which supports the results of external dose calculations for Dolon': recently published soil contamination data, archive information and new models were used for refining dose calculations and the external dose in air for Dolon village was estimated to be about 500 mGy. The results of electron spin resonance (ESR) dosimetry with tooth enamel have demonstrated the notable progress in application of ESR dosimetry to the problems of dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site. At the present moment, dose estimates by the ESR method have become more consistent with calculated values and with retrospective luminescence dosimetry data, but differences between ESR dose estimates and RLD/calculation data were noted. For example mean ESR dose for eligible tooth samples from Dolon' village was estimated to be about 140 mGy (above background dose), which is less than dose values obtained by RLD and calculations. A possible explanation of the differences between ESR and RLD/calculations doses is the following: for interpretation of ESR data the "shielding and behaviour" factors for investigated persons should be taken into account. The "upper level" of the combination of "shielding and behaviour" factors of dose reduction for inhabitants of Dolon' village of about 0.28 was obtained by comparing the individual ESR tooth enamel dose estimates with the calculated mean dose for this settlement. The biological dosimetry data related to the settlements near SNTS were presented at the Workshop. A higher incidence of unstable chromosome aberrations, micronucleus in lymphocytes, nuclear abnormalities of thyroid follicular cells, T-cell receptor mutations in peripheral blood were found for exposed areas (Dolon', Sarjal) in comparison with unexposed ones (Kokpekty). The significant greater frequency of stable translocations (results of analyses of chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes by the FISH technique) was demonstrated for Dolon' village in comparison with Chekoman (unexposed village). The elevated level of stable translocations in Dolon' corresponds to a dose of about 180 mSv, which is close to the results of ESR dosimetry for this village. The importance of investigating specific morphological types of thyroid nodules for thyroid dosimetry studies was pointed out. In general the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop has demonstrated remarkable progress in developing an international level of common approaches for retrospective dose estimations around the SNTS and in understanding the tasks for the future joint work in this direction. In the framework of a special session the problems of developing a database and registry in order to support epidemiological studies around SNTS were discussed. The results of investigation of psychological consequences of nuclear tests, which are expressed in the form of verbal behaviour, were presented at this session as well.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Radiation Research
Volume47
Issue numberSUPPL. A
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Electron Spin Resonance Spectroscopy
dosage
Luminescence
dosimeters
electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy
testing
electron paramagnetic resonance
Kazakhstan
villages
Education
Tooth
luminescence
Dental Enamel
Chromosome Aberrations
Air
Lymphocytes
Verbal Behavior
teeth
Thyroid Nodule
Russia

Keywords

  • Health consequences of irradiation
  • Nuclear tests
  • Retrospective dosimetry
  • Semipanalatinsk

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging
  • Radiological and Ultrasound Technology
  • Radiation

Cite this

Stepanenko, V. F., Hoshi, M., Bailiff, I. K., Ivannikov, A. I., Toyoda, S., Yamamoto, M., ... Apsalikov, K. N. (2006). Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site: Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests. Journal of Radiation Research, 47(SUPPL. A). https://doi.org/10.1269/jrr.47.A1

Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site : Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests. / Stepanenko, Valeriy F.; Hoshi, Masaharu; Bailiff, Ian K.; Ivannikov, Alexander I.; Toyoda, Shin; Yamamoto, Masayoshi; Simon, Steven L.; Matsuo, Masatsugu; Kawano, Noriyuki; Zhumadilov, Zhaxybay; Sasaki, Masao S.; Rosenson, Rafail I.; Apsalikov, Kazbek N.

In: Journal of Radiation Research, Vol. 47, No. SUPPL. A, 2006.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Stepanenko, VF, Hoshi, M, Bailiff, IK, Ivannikov, AI, Toyoda, S, Yamamoto, M, Simon, SL, Matsuo, M, Kawano, N, Zhumadilov, Z, Sasaki, MS, Rosenson, RI & Apsalikov, KN 2006, 'Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site: Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests', Journal of Radiation Research, vol. 47, no. SUPPL. A. https://doi.org/10.1269/jrr.47.A1
Stepanenko, Valeriy F. ; Hoshi, Masaharu ; Bailiff, Ian K. ; Ivannikov, Alexander I. ; Toyoda, Shin ; Yamamoto, Masayoshi ; Simon, Steven L. ; Matsuo, Masatsugu ; Kawano, Noriyuki ; Zhumadilov, Zhaxybay ; Sasaki, Masao S. ; Rosenson, Rafail I. ; Apsalikov, Kazbek N. / Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site : Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests. In: Journal of Radiation Research. 2006 ; Vol. 47, No. SUPPL. A.
@article{630f9e2e465649bb9020cfe747b78261,
title = "Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site: Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests",
abstract = "The paper is an analytical overview of the main results presented at the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop in Hiroshima (9-11 of March 2005), where different aspects of the dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site (SNTS) were discussed and summarized. The results of the international intercomparison of the retrospective luminescence dosimetry (RLD) method for Dolon' village (Kazakhstan) were presented at the Workshop and good concurrence between dose estimations by different laboratories from 6 countries (Japan, Russia, USA, Germany, Finland and UK) was pointed out. The accumulated dose values in brick for a common depth of 10 mm depth obtained independently by all participating laboratories were in good agreement for all four brick samples from Dolon' village, Kazakhstan, with the average value of the local gamma dose due to fallout (near the sampling locations) being about 220 mGy (background dose has been subtracted). Furthermore, using a conversion factor of about 2 to obtain the free-in-air dose, a value of local dose ∼ 440 mGy is obtained, which supports the results of external dose calculations for Dolon': recently published soil contamination data, archive information and new models were used for refining dose calculations and the external dose in air for Dolon village was estimated to be about 500 mGy. The results of electron spin resonance (ESR) dosimetry with tooth enamel have demonstrated the notable progress in application of ESR dosimetry to the problems of dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site. At the present moment, dose estimates by the ESR method have become more consistent with calculated values and with retrospective luminescence dosimetry data, but differences between ESR dose estimates and RLD/calculation data were noted. For example mean ESR dose for eligible tooth samples from Dolon' village was estimated to be about 140 mGy (above background dose), which is less than dose values obtained by RLD and calculations. A possible explanation of the differences between ESR and RLD/calculations doses is the following: for interpretation of ESR data the {"}shielding and behaviour{"} factors for investigated persons should be taken into account. The {"}upper level{"} of the combination of {"}shielding and behaviour{"} factors of dose reduction for inhabitants of Dolon' village of about 0.28 was obtained by comparing the individual ESR tooth enamel dose estimates with the calculated mean dose for this settlement. The biological dosimetry data related to the settlements near SNTS were presented at the Workshop. A higher incidence of unstable chromosome aberrations, micronucleus in lymphocytes, nuclear abnormalities of thyroid follicular cells, T-cell receptor mutations in peripheral blood were found for exposed areas (Dolon', Sarjal) in comparison with unexposed ones (Kokpekty). The significant greater frequency of stable translocations (results of analyses of chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes by the FISH technique) was demonstrated for Dolon' village in comparison with Chekoman (unexposed village). The elevated level of stable translocations in Dolon' corresponds to a dose of about 180 mSv, which is close to the results of ESR dosimetry for this village. The importance of investigating specific morphological types of thyroid nodules for thyroid dosimetry studies was pointed out. In general the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop has demonstrated remarkable progress in developing an international level of common approaches for retrospective dose estimations around the SNTS and in understanding the tasks for the future joint work in this direction. In the framework of a special session the problems of developing a database and registry in order to support epidemiological studies around SNTS were discussed. The results of investigation of psychological consequences of nuclear tests, which are expressed in the form of verbal behaviour, were presented at this session as well.",
keywords = "Health consequences of irradiation, Nuclear tests, Retrospective dosimetry, Semipanalatinsk",
author = "Stepanenko, {Valeriy F.} and Masaharu Hoshi and Bailiff, {Ian K.} and Ivannikov, {Alexander I.} and Shin Toyoda and Masayoshi Yamamoto and Simon, {Steven L.} and Masatsugu Matsuo and Noriyuki Kawano and Zhaxybay Zhumadilov and Sasaki, {Masao S.} and Rosenson, {Rafail I.} and Apsalikov, {Kazbek N.}",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.1269/jrr.47.A1",
language = "English",
volume = "47",
journal = "Journal of Radiation Research",
issn = "0449-3060",
publisher = "Japan Radiation Research Society",
number = "SUPPL. A",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Around semipalatinsk nuclear test site

T2 - Progress of dose estimations relevant to the consequences of nuclear tests

AU - Stepanenko, Valeriy F.

AU - Hoshi, Masaharu

AU - Bailiff, Ian K.

AU - Ivannikov, Alexander I.

AU - Toyoda, Shin

AU - Yamamoto, Masayoshi

AU - Simon, Steven L.

AU - Matsuo, Masatsugu

AU - Kawano, Noriyuki

AU - Zhumadilov, Zhaxybay

AU - Sasaki, Masao S.

AU - Rosenson, Rafail I.

AU - Apsalikov, Kazbek N.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - The paper is an analytical overview of the main results presented at the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop in Hiroshima (9-11 of March 2005), where different aspects of the dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site (SNTS) were discussed and summarized. The results of the international intercomparison of the retrospective luminescence dosimetry (RLD) method for Dolon' village (Kazakhstan) were presented at the Workshop and good concurrence between dose estimations by different laboratories from 6 countries (Japan, Russia, USA, Germany, Finland and UK) was pointed out. The accumulated dose values in brick for a common depth of 10 mm depth obtained independently by all participating laboratories were in good agreement for all four brick samples from Dolon' village, Kazakhstan, with the average value of the local gamma dose due to fallout (near the sampling locations) being about 220 mGy (background dose has been subtracted). Furthermore, using a conversion factor of about 2 to obtain the free-in-air dose, a value of local dose ∼ 440 mGy is obtained, which supports the results of external dose calculations for Dolon': recently published soil contamination data, archive information and new models were used for refining dose calculations and the external dose in air for Dolon village was estimated to be about 500 mGy. The results of electron spin resonance (ESR) dosimetry with tooth enamel have demonstrated the notable progress in application of ESR dosimetry to the problems of dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site. At the present moment, dose estimates by the ESR method have become more consistent with calculated values and with retrospective luminescence dosimetry data, but differences between ESR dose estimates and RLD/calculation data were noted. For example mean ESR dose for eligible tooth samples from Dolon' village was estimated to be about 140 mGy (above background dose), which is less than dose values obtained by RLD and calculations. A possible explanation of the differences between ESR and RLD/calculations doses is the following: for interpretation of ESR data the "shielding and behaviour" factors for investigated persons should be taken into account. The "upper level" of the combination of "shielding and behaviour" factors of dose reduction for inhabitants of Dolon' village of about 0.28 was obtained by comparing the individual ESR tooth enamel dose estimates with the calculated mean dose for this settlement. The biological dosimetry data related to the settlements near SNTS were presented at the Workshop. A higher incidence of unstable chromosome aberrations, micronucleus in lymphocytes, nuclear abnormalities of thyroid follicular cells, T-cell receptor mutations in peripheral blood were found for exposed areas (Dolon', Sarjal) in comparison with unexposed ones (Kokpekty). The significant greater frequency of stable translocations (results of analyses of chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes by the FISH technique) was demonstrated for Dolon' village in comparison with Chekoman (unexposed village). The elevated level of stable translocations in Dolon' corresponds to a dose of about 180 mSv, which is close to the results of ESR dosimetry for this village. The importance of investigating specific morphological types of thyroid nodules for thyroid dosimetry studies was pointed out. In general the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop has demonstrated remarkable progress in developing an international level of common approaches for retrospective dose estimations around the SNTS and in understanding the tasks for the future joint work in this direction. In the framework of a special session the problems of developing a database and registry in order to support epidemiological studies around SNTS were discussed. The results of investigation of psychological consequences of nuclear tests, which are expressed in the form of verbal behaviour, were presented at this session as well.

AB - The paper is an analytical overview of the main results presented at the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop in Hiroshima (9-11 of March 2005), where different aspects of the dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site (SNTS) were discussed and summarized. The results of the international intercomparison of the retrospective luminescence dosimetry (RLD) method for Dolon' village (Kazakhstan) were presented at the Workshop and good concurrence between dose estimations by different laboratories from 6 countries (Japan, Russia, USA, Germany, Finland and UK) was pointed out. The accumulated dose values in brick for a common depth of 10 mm depth obtained independently by all participating laboratories were in good agreement for all four brick samples from Dolon' village, Kazakhstan, with the average value of the local gamma dose due to fallout (near the sampling locations) being about 220 mGy (background dose has been subtracted). Furthermore, using a conversion factor of about 2 to obtain the free-in-air dose, a value of local dose ∼ 440 mGy is obtained, which supports the results of external dose calculations for Dolon': recently published soil contamination data, archive information and new models were used for refining dose calculations and the external dose in air for Dolon village was estimated to be about 500 mGy. The results of electron spin resonance (ESR) dosimetry with tooth enamel have demonstrated the notable progress in application of ESR dosimetry to the problems of dose reconstruction around the Semipalatinsk nuclear test site. At the present moment, dose estimates by the ESR method have become more consistent with calculated values and with retrospective luminescence dosimetry data, but differences between ESR dose estimates and RLD/calculation data were noted. For example mean ESR dose for eligible tooth samples from Dolon' village was estimated to be about 140 mGy (above background dose), which is less than dose values obtained by RLD and calculations. A possible explanation of the differences between ESR and RLD/calculations doses is the following: for interpretation of ESR data the "shielding and behaviour" factors for investigated persons should be taken into account. The "upper level" of the combination of "shielding and behaviour" factors of dose reduction for inhabitants of Dolon' village of about 0.28 was obtained by comparing the individual ESR tooth enamel dose estimates with the calculated mean dose for this settlement. The biological dosimetry data related to the settlements near SNTS were presented at the Workshop. A higher incidence of unstable chromosome aberrations, micronucleus in lymphocytes, nuclear abnormalities of thyroid follicular cells, T-cell receptor mutations in peripheral blood were found for exposed areas (Dolon', Sarjal) in comparison with unexposed ones (Kokpekty). The significant greater frequency of stable translocations (results of analyses of chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes by the FISH technique) was demonstrated for Dolon' village in comparison with Chekoman (unexposed village). The elevated level of stable translocations in Dolon' corresponds to a dose of about 180 mSv, which is close to the results of ESR dosimetry for this village. The importance of investigating specific morphological types of thyroid nodules for thyroid dosimetry studies was pointed out. In general the 3rd Dosimetry Workshop has demonstrated remarkable progress in developing an international level of common approaches for retrospective dose estimations around the SNTS and in understanding the tasks for the future joint work in this direction. In the framework of a special session the problems of developing a database and registry in order to support epidemiological studies around SNTS were discussed. The results of investigation of psychological consequences of nuclear tests, which are expressed in the form of verbal behaviour, were presented at this session as well.

KW - Health consequences of irradiation

KW - Nuclear tests

KW - Retrospective dosimetry

KW - Semipanalatinsk

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33645411208&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33645411208&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1269/jrr.47.A1

DO - 10.1269/jrr.47.A1

M3 - Article

VL - 47

JO - Journal of Radiation Research

JF - Journal of Radiation Research

SN - 0449-3060

IS - SUPPL. A

ER -