Comparative Analysis of Turbulence Models for Automotive Aerodynamic Simulation and Design

Dastan Igali, Olzhas Mukhmetov, Yong Zhao, Sai Cheong Fok, Soo Lee Teh

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The reduction of energy consumption and environmental impacts of road vehicles is always a major design objective. Many investigations suggest that reducing aerodynamic drags such as pressure drag and skin friction drag is a more efficient method than engine modification in achieving the design objective. Turbulent flow around a bluff body is notoriously difficult to simulate accurately due to the complexity of the flow conditions around the body, such as complex flow separation and laminar to turbulent flow transition. This paper investigates the flow over a benchmark model called the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°, which is considered a challenging problem for RANS approach with two-equation turbulence models (Menter, 1994; Serre et al., 2013). Three popular turbulence models, such as the k-ε, k-ω and SST models are evaluated by benchmarking their predictions against experimental data and those of the latest LES solvers. The main purpose of the study is to compare the performances of these models in simulating such a category of flows. In addition, the accuracy and factors that determine the success of such simulation are discussed. Our findings, for the first time, show that with a skillfully generated mesh and proper discretization schemes, the RANS approach with the above two-equation turbulence models are capable of capturing the salient features of the highly complex flow over the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°. The performances are as good as the LES solvers as reported in Serre et al. (2013), if not better for time-averaged flow simulations. The SST model produces the best results among the three models studied. This study could assist designers in the automotive industry in the applications of these cost-effective tools to improve their design productivity. Future study will focus on the performances of the models in simulating time-dependent flows over the Ahmed body.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1145-1152
Number of pages8
JournalInternational Journal of Automotive Technology
Volume20
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 1 2019

Fingerprint

Turbulence models
Aerodynamics
Turbulent flow
Drag
Aerodynamic drag
Flow separation
Skin friction
Flow simulation
Benchmarking
Automotive industry
Environmental impact
Energy utilization
Productivity
Engines
Costs

Keywords

  • Ahmed body
  • Automotive aerodynamics
  • Car aerodynamic design
  • CFD
  • LES
  • Turbulence models

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Automotive Engineering

Cite this

Comparative Analysis of Turbulence Models for Automotive Aerodynamic Simulation and Design. / Igali, Dastan; Mukhmetov, Olzhas; Zhao, Yong; Fok, Sai Cheong; Teh, Soo Lee.

In: International Journal of Automotive Technology, Vol. 20, No. 6, 01.12.2019, p. 1145-1152.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Igali, Dastan ; Mukhmetov, Olzhas ; Zhao, Yong ; Fok, Sai Cheong ; Teh, Soo Lee. / Comparative Analysis of Turbulence Models for Automotive Aerodynamic Simulation and Design. In: International Journal of Automotive Technology. 2019 ; Vol. 20, No. 6. pp. 1145-1152.
@article{a1fdb085415f4e3cbc18e449907c63b2,
title = "Comparative Analysis of Turbulence Models for Automotive Aerodynamic Simulation and Design",
abstract = "The reduction of energy consumption and environmental impacts of road vehicles is always a major design objective. Many investigations suggest that reducing aerodynamic drags such as pressure drag and skin friction drag is a more efficient method than engine modification in achieving the design objective. Turbulent flow around a bluff body is notoriously difficult to simulate accurately due to the complexity of the flow conditions around the body, such as complex flow separation and laminar to turbulent flow transition. This paper investigates the flow over a benchmark model called the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°, which is considered a challenging problem for RANS approach with two-equation turbulence models (Menter, 1994; Serre et al., 2013). Three popular turbulence models, such as the k-ε, k-ω and SST models are evaluated by benchmarking their predictions against experimental data and those of the latest LES solvers. The main purpose of the study is to compare the performances of these models in simulating such a category of flows. In addition, the accuracy and factors that determine the success of such simulation are discussed. Our findings, for the first time, show that with a skillfully generated mesh and proper discretization schemes, the RANS approach with the above two-equation turbulence models are capable of capturing the salient features of the highly complex flow over the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°. The performances are as good as the LES solvers as reported in Serre et al. (2013), if not better for time-averaged flow simulations. The SST model produces the best results among the three models studied. This study could assist designers in the automotive industry in the applications of these cost-effective tools to improve their design productivity. Future study will focus on the performances of the models in simulating time-dependent flows over the Ahmed body.",
keywords = "Ahmed body, Automotive aerodynamics, Car aerodynamic design, CFD, LES, Turbulence models",
author = "Dastan Igali and Olzhas Mukhmetov and Yong Zhao and Fok, {Sai Cheong} and Teh, {Soo Lee}",
year = "2019",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s12239-019-0107-7",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "1145--1152",
journal = "International Journal of Automotive Technology",
issn = "1229-9138",
publisher = "Korean Society of Automotive Engineers",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparative Analysis of Turbulence Models for Automotive Aerodynamic Simulation and Design

AU - Igali, Dastan

AU - Mukhmetov, Olzhas

AU - Zhao, Yong

AU - Fok, Sai Cheong

AU - Teh, Soo Lee

PY - 2019/12/1

Y1 - 2019/12/1

N2 - The reduction of energy consumption and environmental impacts of road vehicles is always a major design objective. Many investigations suggest that reducing aerodynamic drags such as pressure drag and skin friction drag is a more efficient method than engine modification in achieving the design objective. Turbulent flow around a bluff body is notoriously difficult to simulate accurately due to the complexity of the flow conditions around the body, such as complex flow separation and laminar to turbulent flow transition. This paper investigates the flow over a benchmark model called the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°, which is considered a challenging problem for RANS approach with two-equation turbulence models (Menter, 1994; Serre et al., 2013). Three popular turbulence models, such as the k-ε, k-ω and SST models are evaluated by benchmarking their predictions against experimental data and those of the latest LES solvers. The main purpose of the study is to compare the performances of these models in simulating such a category of flows. In addition, the accuracy and factors that determine the success of such simulation are discussed. Our findings, for the first time, show that with a skillfully generated mesh and proper discretization schemes, the RANS approach with the above two-equation turbulence models are capable of capturing the salient features of the highly complex flow over the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°. The performances are as good as the LES solvers as reported in Serre et al. (2013), if not better for time-averaged flow simulations. The SST model produces the best results among the three models studied. This study could assist designers in the automotive industry in the applications of these cost-effective tools to improve their design productivity. Future study will focus on the performances of the models in simulating time-dependent flows over the Ahmed body.

AB - The reduction of energy consumption and environmental impacts of road vehicles is always a major design objective. Many investigations suggest that reducing aerodynamic drags such as pressure drag and skin friction drag is a more efficient method than engine modification in achieving the design objective. Turbulent flow around a bluff body is notoriously difficult to simulate accurately due to the complexity of the flow conditions around the body, such as complex flow separation and laminar to turbulent flow transition. This paper investigates the flow over a benchmark model called the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°, which is considered a challenging problem for RANS approach with two-equation turbulence models (Menter, 1994; Serre et al., 2013). Three popular turbulence models, such as the k-ε, k-ω and SST models are evaluated by benchmarking their predictions against experimental data and those of the latest LES solvers. The main purpose of the study is to compare the performances of these models in simulating such a category of flows. In addition, the accuracy and factors that determine the success of such simulation are discussed. Our findings, for the first time, show that with a skillfully generated mesh and proper discretization schemes, the RANS approach with the above two-equation turbulence models are capable of capturing the salient features of the highly complex flow over the Ahmed body with a slant angle of 25°. The performances are as good as the LES solvers as reported in Serre et al. (2013), if not better for time-averaged flow simulations. The SST model produces the best results among the three models studied. This study could assist designers in the automotive industry in the applications of these cost-effective tools to improve their design productivity. Future study will focus on the performances of the models in simulating time-dependent flows over the Ahmed body.

KW - Ahmed body

KW - Automotive aerodynamics

KW - Car aerodynamic design

KW - CFD

KW - LES

KW - Turbulence models

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85073255463&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85073255463&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s12239-019-0107-7

DO - 10.1007/s12239-019-0107-7

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85073255463

VL - 20

SP - 1145

EP - 1152

JO - International Journal of Automotive Technology

JF - International Journal of Automotive Technology

SN - 1229-9138

IS - 6

ER -