Confucian Political Obligation of the People: the Argument from Gratitude

Shu-Shan Lee

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

This study is about the theory of Confucian political obligation. While researchers have offered different theories of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I argue that these accounts are problematic. The paper suggests that Confucian theory of political obligation is neither role-based, nor simply reciprocal, nor grounded in voluntary acceptance. In a nutshell, it is based on a special principle of gratitude. After comparing Confucian political obligation with liberal gratitude theory, I note this Confucian theory’s incompatibility with the liberal principle of voluntary choice. To accurately describe the theory of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I conclude that Confucian political obligation is a theory of paternalistic gratitude.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationthe Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association
Place of PublicationChicago, United States
Pages1-31
Number of pages31
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Confucian
Gratitude
Political Obligation
Confucianism
Acceptance

Keywords

  • Confucianism, Reciprocity, Gratitude, Paternalism, Political Obligation

Cite this

Lee, S-S. (2014). Confucian Political Obligation of the People: the Argument from Gratitude. In the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association (pp. 1-31). Chicago, United States.

Confucian Political Obligation of the People : the Argument from Gratitude. / Lee, Shu-Shan.

the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association. Chicago, United States, 2014. p. 1-31.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Lee, S-S 2014, Confucian Political Obligation of the People: the Argument from Gratitude. in the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association. Chicago, United States, pp. 1-31.
Lee S-S. Confucian Political Obligation of the People: the Argument from Gratitude. In the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association. Chicago, United States. 2014. p. 1-31
Lee, Shu-Shan. / Confucian Political Obligation of the People : the Argument from Gratitude. the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association. Chicago, United States, 2014. pp. 1-31
@inproceedings{40604f8963ee4533a078b8717d070c37,
title = "Confucian Political Obligation of the People: the Argument from Gratitude",
abstract = "This study is about the theory of Confucian political obligation. While researchers have offered different theories of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I argue that these accounts are problematic. The paper suggests that Confucian theory of political obligation is neither role-based, nor simply reciprocal, nor grounded in voluntary acceptance. In a nutshell, it is based on a special principle of gratitude. After comparing Confucian political obligation with liberal gratitude theory, I note this Confucian theory’s incompatibility with the liberal principle of voluntary choice. To accurately describe the theory of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I conclude that Confucian political obligation is a theory of paternalistic gratitude.",
keywords = "Confucianism, Reciprocity, Gratitude, Paternalism, Political Obligation",
author = "Shu-Shan Lee",
year = "2014",
language = "English",
pages = "1--31",
booktitle = "the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Confucian Political Obligation of the People

T2 - the Argument from Gratitude

AU - Lee, Shu-Shan

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - This study is about the theory of Confucian political obligation. While researchers have offered different theories of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I argue that these accounts are problematic. The paper suggests that Confucian theory of political obligation is neither role-based, nor simply reciprocal, nor grounded in voluntary acceptance. In a nutshell, it is based on a special principle of gratitude. After comparing Confucian political obligation with liberal gratitude theory, I note this Confucian theory’s incompatibility with the liberal principle of voluntary choice. To accurately describe the theory of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I conclude that Confucian political obligation is a theory of paternalistic gratitude.

AB - This study is about the theory of Confucian political obligation. While researchers have offered different theories of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I argue that these accounts are problematic. The paper suggests that Confucian theory of political obligation is neither role-based, nor simply reciprocal, nor grounded in voluntary acceptance. In a nutshell, it is based on a special principle of gratitude. After comparing Confucian political obligation with liberal gratitude theory, I note this Confucian theory’s incompatibility with the liberal principle of voluntary choice. To accurately describe the theory of political obligation in classical Confucianism, I conclude that Confucian political obligation is a theory of paternalistic gratitude.

KW - Confucianism, Reciprocity, Gratitude, Paternalism, Political Obligation

M3 - Conference contribution

SP - 1

EP - 31

BT - the Annual Conference of Midwest Political Science Association

CY - Chicago, United States

ER -