Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits

Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen, Francesco Bellucci

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

We explain the grammar and the critics of the habits of reasoning in Peirce's 1903 Lowell Lectures and the Syllabus. We can derive a soundness result concerning his logic as semeiotic: an argument is valid if for any object that the premises represent, the conclusion represents it as well, which in semeiotic terms translates to a sign being a valid argument if for any object that the sign represents, the interpretant sign represents it as well. The perfect adherence of the grammar to the critics is evidenced by the un-eliminability of leading principles. Just as a logical leading principle is an un-eliminable element of reasoning, because any attempt to use it as a premise engenders an infinite regress, so a logical representative interpretant is a habit that cannot be rendered a sign. The logical representative interpretant is a principle not itself a premise, a rule not itself subject to rules, a habit not itself a sign.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationHabit: Before and Beyond Consciousness
Subtitle of host publicationStudies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics
Pages265--282
Volume31
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Grammar
Habit
Logic
Interpretant
Semeiotic
Adherence
Valid Arguments
Syllabus
Infinite Regress

Cite this

Pietarinen, A-V., & Bellucci, F. (2017). Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits. In Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness: Studies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics (Vol. 31, pp. 265--282)

Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits. / Pietarinen, Ahti-Veikko; Bellucci, Francesco.

Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness: Studies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics. Vol. 31 2017. p. 265--282.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Pietarinen, A-V & Bellucci, F 2017, Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits. in Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness: Studies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics. vol. 31, pp. 265--282.
Pietarinen A-V, Bellucci F. Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits. In Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness: Studies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics. Vol. 31. 2017. p. 265--282
Pietarinen, Ahti-Veikko ; Bellucci, Francesco. / Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits. Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness: Studies in Applied Philosophy, Epistemology and Rational Ethics. Vol. 31 2017. pp. 265--282
@inbook{e61a681ed1fc47628139926d06287025,
title = "Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits",
abstract = "We explain the grammar and the critics of the habits of reasoning in Peirce's 1903 Lowell Lectures and the Syllabus. We can derive a soundness result concerning his logic as semeiotic: an argument is valid if for any object that the premises represent, the conclusion represents it as well, which in semeiotic terms translates to a sign being a valid argument if for any object that the sign represents, the interpretant sign represents it as well. The perfect adherence of the grammar to the critics is evidenced by the un-eliminability of leading principles. Just as a logical leading principle is an un-eliminable element of reasoning, because any attempt to use it as a premise engenders an infinite regress, so a logical representative interpretant is a habit that cannot be rendered a sign. The logical representative interpretant is a principle not itself a premise, a rule not itself subject to rules, a habit not itself a sign.",
author = "Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen and Francesco Bellucci",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-3319459189",
volume = "31",
pages = "265----282",
booktitle = "Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Habits of Reasoning. On the Grammar and Critics of Logical Habits

AU - Pietarinen, Ahti-Veikko

AU - Bellucci, Francesco

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - We explain the grammar and the critics of the habits of reasoning in Peirce's 1903 Lowell Lectures and the Syllabus. We can derive a soundness result concerning his logic as semeiotic: an argument is valid if for any object that the premises represent, the conclusion represents it as well, which in semeiotic terms translates to a sign being a valid argument if for any object that the sign represents, the interpretant sign represents it as well. The perfect adherence of the grammar to the critics is evidenced by the un-eliminability of leading principles. Just as a logical leading principle is an un-eliminable element of reasoning, because any attempt to use it as a premise engenders an infinite regress, so a logical representative interpretant is a habit that cannot be rendered a sign. The logical representative interpretant is a principle not itself a premise, a rule not itself subject to rules, a habit not itself a sign.

AB - We explain the grammar and the critics of the habits of reasoning in Peirce's 1903 Lowell Lectures and the Syllabus. We can derive a soundness result concerning his logic as semeiotic: an argument is valid if for any object that the premises represent, the conclusion represents it as well, which in semeiotic terms translates to a sign being a valid argument if for any object that the sign represents, the interpretant sign represents it as well. The perfect adherence of the grammar to the critics is evidenced by the un-eliminability of leading principles. Just as a logical leading principle is an un-eliminable element of reasoning, because any attempt to use it as a premise engenders an infinite regress, so a logical representative interpretant is a habit that cannot be rendered a sign. The logical representative interpretant is a principle not itself a premise, a rule not itself subject to rules, a habit not itself a sign.

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

SN - 978-3319459189

VL - 31

SP - 265

EP - 282

BT - Habit: Before and Beyond Consciousness

ER -