Neoliberal reform and protest in Latin American democracies: A replication and correction

Frederick Solt, Dongkyu Kim, Kyu Young Lee, Spencer Willardson, Seokdong Kim

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Do neoliberal economic reforms in Latin American democracies mobilize citizens to overcome their collective action
problems and protest? A recent addition to the scholarship on this crucial question of the relationship of markets and
politics, Bellinger and Arce (2011), concludes that economic liberalization does have this effect, working to repoliticize
collective actors and reinvigorate democracy. We reexamine the article’s analyses and demonstrate that they misinterpret
the marginal effect of the variables of theoretical interest. Thus, the article’s optimistic claims about the consequences
for democracy of economic liberalization in the region are not supported by its own empirical results. It is argued here
that its results suggest instead that protests became more common in autocracies when they moved away from markets.
Rather than speaking to how people have mobilized to protest against liberal reforms in Latin America’s democracies,
the work’s analyses illuminate only when people protested against the region’s dictatorships.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-13
Number of pages13
JournalResearch and Politics
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

protest
democracy
reform
liberalization
market
dictatorship
economic reform
economics
speaking
Latin America
citizen

Keywords

  • Neoliberal Reform
  • Political Protest
  • Latin America

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Political Science and International Relations

Cite this

Neoliberal reform and protest in Latin American democracies : A replication and correction. / Solt, Frederick; Kim, Dongkyu; Lee, Kyu Young; Willardson, Spencer; Kim, Seokdong.

In: Research and Politics, 2014, p. 1-13.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Solt, Frederick ; Kim, Dongkyu ; Lee, Kyu Young ; Willardson, Spencer ; Kim, Seokdong. / Neoliberal reform and protest in Latin American democracies : A replication and correction. In: Research and Politics. 2014 ; pp. 1-13.
@article{fdccbeecca334784ac351392f8bfd83e,
title = "Neoliberal reform and protest in Latin American democracies: A replication and correction",
abstract = "Do neoliberal economic reforms in Latin American democracies mobilize citizens to overcome their collective actionproblems and protest? A recent addition to the scholarship on this crucial question of the relationship of markets andpolitics, Bellinger and Arce (2011), concludes that economic liberalization does have this effect, working to repoliticizecollective actors and reinvigorate democracy. We reexamine the article’s analyses and demonstrate that they misinterpretthe marginal effect of the variables of theoretical interest. Thus, the article’s optimistic claims about the consequencesfor democracy of economic liberalization in the region are not supported by its own empirical results. It is argued herethat its results suggest instead that protests became more common in autocracies when they moved away from markets.Rather than speaking to how people have mobilized to protest against liberal reforms in Latin America’s democracies,the work’s analyses illuminate only when people protested against the region’s dictatorships.",
keywords = "Neoliberal Reform, Political Protest, Latin America",
author = "Frederick Solt and Dongkyu Kim and Lee, {Kyu Young} and Spencer Willardson and Seokdong Kim",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1177/2053168014545413",
language = "English",
pages = "1--13",
journal = "Research and Politics",
issn = "2053-1680",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Neoliberal reform and protest in Latin American democracies

T2 - A replication and correction

AU - Solt, Frederick

AU - Kim, Dongkyu

AU - Lee, Kyu Young

AU - Willardson, Spencer

AU - Kim, Seokdong

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Do neoliberal economic reforms in Latin American democracies mobilize citizens to overcome their collective actionproblems and protest? A recent addition to the scholarship on this crucial question of the relationship of markets andpolitics, Bellinger and Arce (2011), concludes that economic liberalization does have this effect, working to repoliticizecollective actors and reinvigorate democracy. We reexamine the article’s analyses and demonstrate that they misinterpretthe marginal effect of the variables of theoretical interest. Thus, the article’s optimistic claims about the consequencesfor democracy of economic liberalization in the region are not supported by its own empirical results. It is argued herethat its results suggest instead that protests became more common in autocracies when they moved away from markets.Rather than speaking to how people have mobilized to protest against liberal reforms in Latin America’s democracies,the work’s analyses illuminate only when people protested against the region’s dictatorships.

AB - Do neoliberal economic reforms in Latin American democracies mobilize citizens to overcome their collective actionproblems and protest? A recent addition to the scholarship on this crucial question of the relationship of markets andpolitics, Bellinger and Arce (2011), concludes that economic liberalization does have this effect, working to repoliticizecollective actors and reinvigorate democracy. We reexamine the article’s analyses and demonstrate that they misinterpretthe marginal effect of the variables of theoretical interest. Thus, the article’s optimistic claims about the consequencesfor democracy of economic liberalization in the region are not supported by its own empirical results. It is argued herethat its results suggest instead that protests became more common in autocracies when they moved away from markets.Rather than speaking to how people have mobilized to protest against liberal reforms in Latin America’s democracies,the work’s analyses illuminate only when people protested against the region’s dictatorships.

KW - Neoliberal Reform

KW - Political Protest

KW - Latin America

U2 - 10.1177/2053168014545413

DO - 10.1177/2053168014545413

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 13

JO - Research and Politics

JF - Research and Politics

SN - 2053-1680

ER -